{ "review_id": "fusion-ppc-system-audit-20260830", "date": "2026-08-30", "orchestrator": { "model": "claude-opus-5", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "host": "lifeos-devbox (juno)", "tmux_session": "fusion", "working_dir": "/home/matt/mirror/Fusion", "branch": "round-13-takeover", "baseline_commit": "8351b59" }, "goal": { "file": "goal-v1.md", "sha256": "287532968913b5b5fda888cdf38f02496a523ed2314f4da91e4d4ba3b49690e8", "versions": 1, "frozen": true, "acceptance_rows": 15, "acceptance_result": "15/15 PASS", "ledger": "acceptance-ledger.md" }, "mission": { "file": "handoffs/2026-08-30-fusion-ppc-system-audit.md", "mode": "review and planning only", "ship_gate": "absent — mission contains no 'SHIP: true', so main was not touched and nothing was deployed" }, "executors": [ { "lane": 1, "name": "requirements traceability and 16-flow user-flow matrix", "model": "claude-opus-5", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "status": "READY_FOR_PARENT_ACCEPTANCE", "artifacts": ["requirements-traceability.md", "user-flow-matrix.md"], "rows": {"requirements": 51, "flows": 66}, "tool_uses": 53, "duration_ms": 1691660 }, { "lane": 2, "name": "live browser and UX review at 1280x900 DSF1", "model": "claude-opus-5", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "status": "READY_FOR_PARENT_ACCEPTANCE", "artifacts": ["browser-test-ledger.md", "evidence/lane2/"], "targets_tested": 10, "interactions": {"pass": 38, "fail": 33}, "tool_uses": 72, "duration_ms": 1732658 }, { "lane": 3, "name": "measurement data contracts and orchestration trigger audit", "model": "claude-opus-5", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "status": "READY_FOR_PARENT_ACCEPTANCE", "artifacts": ["measurement-and-trigger-ledger.md"], "rows": {"measurement": 38, "triggers": 7}, "tool_uses": 48, "duration_ms": 1792544 }, { "lane": 4, "name": "Matt Pocock code-review (Standards + Spec) and Ponytail complexity audit", "model": "claude-opus-5", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "status": "READY_FOR_PARENT_ACCEPTANCE", "artifacts": ["matt-pocock-code-review.md", "ponytail-audit.md"] }, { "lane": 5, "name": "outside-the-box business and operating-model challenge", "model": "claude-opus-5", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "status": "READY_FOR_PARENT_ACCEPTANCE", "artifacts": ["outside-the-box-review.md"], "challenges": {"total": 25, "critical": 6, "high": 8} } ], "findings": { "file": "consolidated-findings.md", "total": 30, "critical": 7, "high": 8, "medium": 10, "low": 5, "id_range": "F-01..F-30" }, "plan": { "file": "enhance-simplify-align-plan.md", "groups": 6, "addendum": "P0 group added after lanes 1 and 2 landed; the repair order was re-sequenced so the cache fix precedes the CRM source column", "dispositions": [ "APPLY NOW", "APPLY AFTER MORE DATA", "KEEP AS SAFETY CONTROL", "REMOVE OR MERGE", "NEEDS MATT'S DECISION", "FUTURE IDEA" ] }, "orchestrator_corrections": [ { "id": "ORCH-CORR-1", "claim_corrected": "the handoff named 638e7524 as the reviewed fixed point", "check": "git merge-base --is-ancestor 638e7524 round-13-takeover", "result": "false — the commit is reachable only from origin/codex/fusion-ppc-architecture-orchestrator; 41 files were absent from every child worktree" }, { "id": "ORCH-CORR-2", "claim_corrected": "conversion counts represent enquiries", "check": "read ppc.conversion_actions and meta_ads.actions in report_data.json", "result": "46 of 49 Google conversions and all 14 Meta results are vhk_form_start" }, { "id": "ORCH-CORR-3", "claim_corrected": "the KPC advice system produces actionable output", "check": "read advice_output-20260824T111713-2aa95a23.json", "result": "61 of 61 rows in wait_for_evidence; config excludes PMax, which carries 100% of spend" }, { "id": "ORCH-CORR-4", "claim_corrected": "the T1 to T2 dependency gate passed against an integrated commit", "check": "git branch -a --contains b1013882", "result": "returns only codex/fusion-ppc-t2-audit — the gate's own stated precondition was unsatisfied; the content did land via 4459dfe, so the receipt failed, not the evidence" }, { "id": "ORCH-CORR-5", "claim_corrected": "lane 5 reported both page-load conversion URLs as malformed", "check": "curl -L on both URLs, 2026-08-30", "result": "https://fusiontables.hu/biliard/biliard 404 and /biliard/ 404, so Submit lead form cannot fire; https://fusiontables.hu/billiardasztal/billiardasztal 200, so Purchase is an armed trap rather than a dead one" }, { "id": "ORCH-CORR-6", "claim_corrected": "the orchestrator's own ground truth said T2 produced no artifacts", "check": "git -C /home/matt/mirror/Fusion-ppc-children/t2 status --porcelain -uall", "result": "2 modified and 5 untracked files totalling 313 lines of real audit work — true of git, false of disk; lane 3 refuted the claim and the orchestrator verified and corrected it" } ], "validators_run": [ "git merge-base --is-ancestor / git branch --contains / git rev-list — branch identity of every cited fixed point", "git log --all --diff-filter=A — existence of ads-control/reports/stage-3-20260824T111713-2aa95a23.html on any branch (result: none)", "curl -L on both page-load conversion URLs", "grep at index.html:460 and :519 — the render path that overwrites the fetch failure message", "grep at deck.js:26-33 — only the agent name is interpolated into the ABSTAIN card body", "read of tracking-audit.md cache section at source — the P0 cache-poisoning observation", "two-sided binomial test on 13 vs 7 enquiries — p = 0.263", "index.html internal link resolution — 16 links, 0 broken", "git diff --name-only 8351b59..HEAD — mutation scope confinement" ], "browser_evidence": { "dir": "evidence/lane2", "screenshots": 36, "receipts": 17, "viewport": "1280x900", "device_scale_factor": 1, "engine": "Playwright", "shared_chrome_touched": false }, "authority_and_safety": { "spend_usd": 0, "spend_cap_usd": 12, "credentials_read": 0, "live_ads_or_meta_changes": 0, "campaign_budget_or_targeting_changes": 0, "ga4_gtm_pixel_capi_crm_wordpress_production_mutations": 0, "client_or_lead_messages_sent": 0, "accepted_deliverables_replaced_or_deleted": 0, "merges_or_deploys": 0, "main_branch": "untouched at 21d6873", "child_branches": "untouched", "build_run": "not restarted, not resumed, not repaired", "mutation_scope": "outputs/reviews/fusion-ppc-system-audit-20260830/ and docs/runs/ only" }, "limitations": [ "delegate-to-session-w-goal-loop's persistent transport is Codex-only (gpt-5.6-sol), which conflicts with the mission's explicit instruction not to downgrade to Codex or Sol. The five lanes therefore ran as in-process Claude Opus executors preserving every other element of the skill's logic: frozen checksum-addressed goal, per-lane return contract, parent independent revalidation. Recorded as a deviation, not presented as compliance.", "Lane effort inherited the session default xhigh rather than the mandated high. At or above the mandate, never below.", "Matt's verbatim requirement quotes were taken from the handoff and GROUND-TRUTH.md, not re-derived from the raw transcripts, which are Mac-local and unavailable on this host.", "No live Google Ads, Meta Ads, GA4, GTM, Search Console, Notion or CRM reads. All account facts come from the accepted T1 corpus, T2's registered receipts, or the materialised report_data.json and KPC ledgers.", "No test form submission was made, so the cache-poisoning defect's exact downstream impact remains as the July auditors left it: directly observed, impact not proven.", "The mechanism of the two process deaths is a hypothesis — dmesg needs root and journalctl shows no kill record for 12:32-12:34. The total absence of any watcher is proven, not hypothesised.", "Lane 2's Meta dashboard success path was driven with a synthetic scratchpad fixture because the real data files exist on no branch. The structural findings are value-independent; no fixture number is reported as a Fusion figure.", "The 1,524-row field_ledger and the two ~21.7k-line evidence ledgers were sampled, not exhaustively audited." ], "remaining_human_actions": [ "Approve the repair sequence, which begins with the page-cache fix and not with the CRM source column.", "Decide the units question: label funnel axes in events, clicks and sessions rather than people, which is what every available source actually measures.", "Decide the Google account structure, since one Performance Max campaign cannot support a creative or targeting comparison.", "Decide whether the KPC keyword system is repointed at PMax search themes or shelved until Search is re-enabled.", "Authorise the live Google Ads and Meta changes in F-01 and F-02, which this review is explicitly not permitted to make.", "Decide whether to salvage T2's 313 uncommitted lines before any relaunch decision." ], "commits": { "branch": "round-13-takeover", "note": "review commits only; see docs/runs/2026-08-30-fusion-juno.md for the run record" }, "return_contract": "READY_FOR_PARENT_ACCEPTANCE" }