Komplex LogopédiaReview evidence and decisions

Complete review index · Original Markdown

Report

Status: DONE

Result

The assigned legacy staging work is ready for parent integration. The September master now appends 267 individually labelled critique targets covering every substantive incumbent file, including all 20 ads, 82 email alternatives and 76 actual landing sections. The original 29 embeds remain in order, and only the outer index changes.

This is saved critique content and a locally verified single-layer adapter. Provider persistence and deployed browser acceptance remain parent-owned and unverified. This report does not call the full journey package complete.

Deliverables and checks

Deliverable Requirement or verification Result Evidence
Staged master (local evidence: /Users/agency/Documents/Agty/KomplexLogopédia/outputs/rita-journey-20261002/legacy/staged/index.html) Preserve original master identity, embeds, document ID and professional/commercial wording PASS Only original index.html differs. All 29 iframe source paths and their order remain. The only pre-append copy change is replacing 29 inner-comment instructions with outer-layer instructions. Stable parent publication destination is https://review.clientsflow.hu/komplex-rita-funnel-2026-09-26-v1/, document komplex-rita-funnel-20260926-master.
Compact inventory (local evidence: /Users/agency/Documents/Agty/KomplexLogopédia/outputs/rita-journey-20261002/legacy/inventory.json) Every individual asset and substantive source represented PASS 267 targets. Counts: 20 current ad packages, 8 historical original creatives, 82 email alternatives, 76 landing sections, 28 A/B daily screen alternatives, 14 Markdown day downloads, 18 module formats, 6 testimonial invitations, 2 Rita review emails, 12 assembled surfaces and 1 logo family. 135 source files represented, 2 QA fixtures excluded with reason, 1 shared stylesheet retained as technical support. Zero unaccounted files.
Full critique index (local evidence: /Users/agency/Documents/Agty/KomplexLogopédia/outputs/rita-journey-20261002/legacy/critique-index.md) Concrete original identity, overview difficulty, attention order, internal reasoning, weakness, change and next thought for every item PASS Each target has all seven required content fields. Email A/B and delivery/reminder critiques are distinct, with day-specific problems. Landing critique covers sec-01 to sec-19 in all four files, including actual heroes and footers. No individual ad relies solely on its incumbent generic self-critique.
Comments-ready records (local evidence: /Users/agency/Documents/Agty/KomplexLogopédia/outputs/rita-journey-20261002/legacy/comments-ready.json) Stable outer targets and honest persistence label PASS 267 distinct legacy-* data-cid targets match 267 unique record IDs and texts. Records state pending_no_remote_write. No backend write, invented backend, account upgrade, test comment or live persistence probe was performed. The static critique HTML visibly distinguishes its saved content from unknown provider persistence.
Static acceptance Complete count, target uniqueness, source identity and zero inventory omissions PASS Reproducible command: python3 outputs/rita-journey-20261002/legacy/build_legacy_review.py. Output: 267 unique targets, 29 embeds preserved, original changed files exactly [index.html], no missing inventory file.
Link/runtime checks Important actual source links and existing injected runtimes retained PASS All 267 source files/HTML fragments resolve locally. Every original injected comment runtime block is byte-identical in staging. All 137 original files other than index are byte-identical, so child document IDs, DOM targets and inline-edit application code remain intact.
Adapter fixture test Only outer layer visible in same-origin master without removing inner history/runtime PASS node outputs/rita-journey-20261002/legacy/test_adapter.cjs passes DOM fixtures for hidden inner host/toolbar/pins/composer, forced-off inner interaction, keyboard re-enable suppression, one adapter per document, cross-origin preservation and outer refresh. The adapter lives only in the outer index and inserts styles into same-origin iframe documents at runtime. Standalone child files have no suppression patch. This is a fixture proof, not a browser screenshot claim.
Daily source check Criticism of daily source completeness must be grounded PASS All 14 canonical daily paragraph sets are present in both the old HTML and Markdown. Day 8's four verse columns are specifically verified through its Markdown table transformation. Therefore the critique identifies navigation, load, unpersisted reflection and simulated video/feedback weaknesses, without inventing missing canonical text.
PDF extraction check Inspect actual substantive historical PDF content PASS Actual 6 PDFs were extracted with pypdf. Critiques identify old alternate-day delivery, 48-hour reflections, implied videos, unsupported proof labels and the old 60/90-day upsell. The supplied module-text extraction was read as supporting context and is not falsely claimed byte/text-identical to pypdf extraction.
F creatives, N01–N06, N07–N12, Historical originals Genuine image inspection for all visual hooks PASS All 20 derived images and 8 historical originals were inspected from local contact sheets. Findings are observable communication issues, such as studio gear, video-call imagery, play symbols, linear stairs, calendar symbols and unsupported old proof labels. No screenshot-based mobile aesthetic pass is claimed.
Original archive (local evidence: /Users/agency/Documents/Agty/KomplexLogopédia/outputs/rita-journey-20261002/legacy/incumbent-original.tar.gz), Original index (local evidence: /Users/agency/Documents/Agty/KomplexLogopédia/evidence/legacy/original-index.html), Checksums Practical narrow recovery and unchanged source bytes PASS Archive readback proof: all 138 archived original files match their original hashes. Restore only the index from the preserved byte-identical original-index.html for a narrow rollback. The archive can restore all original assets if needed.
Stable URL readback, outer visible layer and mobile client surfaces at 360/390/430 Parent-owned deployment/browser acceptance NOT CHECKED No live mirror, deployment, renderer, board, new flow or mobile customer interface was changed by this child. Parent must publish the staged tree to the same stable URL and ID, inject its current shared outer runtime, and perform actual deployed QA.
Provider comments and inline rewrites survive reload Parent-owned remote persistence acceptance NOT CHECKED The previously reported HTML fallback/Cloudflare plan limit was respected. This child did not probe or fake persistence. Existing comment IDs and inner runtime/history paths remain preserved, but backend records could not be read back here.

Limits or consequential decisions